Cayuga Lake 4/21, Seneca Lake 4/22

4/21:  Cayuga Lake out of Long Point State Park:  BTW:  The park here still hasn't officially "opened," so there is no entrance fee and the restrooms remain locked.

We just had another day/evening of rain and around  .75" to 1" was recorded throughout much of the region.  Over the past 7 days, according to the Rainy App, we've had up to 2.5" of rain!   The accompanying strong cold front gave us a snowy day on Sunday night and Monday throughout the day along with some north winds.  This makes fishing tougher and sets the spring fishing back.

All of this was evident when setting out for a full-day of lake trout jigging on Tuesday.  Cayuga Lake was back up at a low flood stage.  Baitfish appear to have moved deep again.  The lake trout bite was between neutral and negative for us.  It was a slow day, but Rachel managed 3 solid fish in the 27" to 29" range.  Her dad Ron landed one.  A few fish were also missed.

I will be back out targeting lake trout here shortly, and with the warm trend moving in, I expect fishing to get better by the day.  The lake conditions were excellent - the clarity was very good, so the slow fishing was likely due to the cold front.  We did not see a single other boat out fishing today!  That is rare for Cayuga Lake in 2026!

4/22:  Today was a 6-hour trip, again with Ron and Rachel, but on Seneca Lake out of Watkins Glen.  The effects of the heavy rains from a few days ago and cold front were also noticeable here.  The lake is a couple inches down from being as high as I've seen it this spring.   There is a staggering amount of "fishy green water" and trying to locate salmon via casting over the past week just became much more challenging!  That being said, water temperatures are still conducive to fish being up top and nearshore, so we aren't done with the salmon casting quite yet, but the relatively easy consistent fishing (for this season, that is,) is certainly in the rearview mirror.  I can't complain - we did very well on salmon, browns and rainbows starting back in November and right up to last week or perhaps two weeks ago!  You won't get any complaints from this guide!

We started off promisingly with Ron nabbing a nice 17" salmon on our first drift.  Rachel then had a very good one follow in her lure - I got a glimpse of this fish and it was around 22" to 23" or so.  In another area Rachel nabbed another 17"er.  We tried two other areas, but we had some time constraints today.  I was not able to really get Ron and Rachel covering the water I was hoping to work, due to the distance from the launch.  Rachel had another hit in our first area, but that was it - so it was a tough day.

Rachel got us started on Tuesday!

Her second fish of the day

Her best one of the day! She can fish!

Ron's late day lake trout

The Aurora Market is having some renovations done, so it was closed.  I believe it'll be closed for a couple of weeks.  That can be a great place to pick up some sandwiches and coffee.  They also will direct people who need to use a restroom to the Aurora Inn next door.  It's nice to be able to pull up to their dock and take a quick break if needed.  The food there is fantastic - really top-notch and the prices are very reasonable.  I suggest calling them ahead of time if looking for food, since they do run out and the day-to-day selection can vary a lot.

I wasn't thrilled with our results over the past two days, but we have had nearly 4.5" of rain over the past three weeks!  I'm happy that we're still able to get out onto the lakes and fish.  Things can always be worse!  Some launches may still be closed on Seneca Lake - I'm not sure.  Severne Point was closed due to debris.  I think we're on the right track and I expect good fishing for lake trout in the coming months.

What I'm looking forward to:

Pike season opens up on May 1st.  I expect decent fishing on Owasco Lake.  On Seneca, we can try for northerns and I can combine that with laker jigging from Sampson State Park north or with salmon casting in the southern portions of the lake.

Skaneateles Lake tends to cough up a few walleyes for us in late-April and May.  Smallmouth fishing can be fantastic in May and we also catch some lakers, jumbo perch and other bonus fish.

We'll be doing a little more shallow lake trout fishing on Keuka Lake.  Will we see any more walleyes?  Stay tuned!

Lake trout jigging should be getting good on all the major Finger Lakes in May.  Like I said before, I expect Cayuga Lake to pick up markedly.  And did I mention Cayuga Lake's brown trout in the southern portions of the lake?  Those and rainbows should provide some fly-fishing and spin-casting opportunities going into May.  Lakers can also be taken lake-wide, so I can combine casting and jigging trips.


Spread The Word

Share this post